Calculation frameworks for quantifying the return on investment (ROI) of a brand protection service can take a variety of forms. Many frameworks are built around the idea of the total value of goods removed via takedowns of infringing listings from e-commerce marketplaces. However, additional sophistication can be built into the approach, by considering factors such as assumed prices and quantities, data caps, substitution rates and long-term changes to the infringement landscape. Overall, the optimum strategy is to have a flexible range of frameworks, which can be tailored to client requirements in any given case.
Calculating ROI: The Basics
As part of a general review of our data reporting capabilities at SnapDragon (and in conjunction with the standardisation of our terminology, as discussed in Part 5 of Brand Protection Notebook), we have been exploring the ways in which return on investment can be calculated in our summary reports.
ROI calculations are most commonly carried out following a period of enforcement, involving the removal of infringing listings from e-commerce marketplace platforms. One of the simplest types of calculation involves determining the total value of goods removed, which can be expressed as the product of the item price and the number of items available in each listing, summed up over all removed listings.
The approach is straightforward in cases where price and quantity information is available on every listing, but this is not always the case. For many platforms, the relevant data fields are readily available and can be extracted via an API (where our monitoring tool extracts the information directly from the platform at a database level) or through the use of a site ‘scraper’. Scrapers can be used when the layout of a platform’s listing pages is known in advance, allowing the system to be configured to extract the relevant information from its known location. However, for many platforms, the information may not be provided in a consistent format, or may not be made available at all.
As a result, an ROI calculation may need to be modified to take account of instances where some of the data points are missing. One option is to use the information as given, wherever it is available, but to assume a value for the respective field where it is not. A very common approach is to assume the available quantity of items to be 1 (essentially, the minimum possible quantity) if no explicit quantity information is given. This thereby gives a lower bound (or most conservative estimate) of the ‘actual’ numbers and/or value of items enforced.
However, this approach does mean that not all platforms are treated equally, depending on how much data they make available. An alternative possibility is to assume that every listing corresponds to a single available item, giving a measure which may be described as the ‘minimum removed stock volume’. Other metrics, such as the average price across all enforced listings, can also be informative.
Additional factors can further complicate the situation. One example is where the price or quantity information cited in a listing is unrealistically high. This can occur for a number of reasons. For example, some sellers may specify very high quantities of available items, to imply that they are willing to produce and ship on demand as many products as are requested by a buyer. Alternatively, recent analysis by SnapDragon’s Analyst team suggests that some sellers will specify very high prices to keep out-of-stock listings active, as a way of maintaining their search ranking and visibility.
One option in these cases is to specify a data ‘cap’, whereby any value in the listing that exceeds a particular threshold is reset to that threshold when the calculation is performed. However, this approach introduces another layer of assumptions and, as with the missing data, can mean that listings and platforms are not treated equally.
Exploring Alternative ROI Measures
Going forward, we are also exploring other approaches to the calculation of ROI. One option is to include consideration of factors such as the ‘substitution rate’ (i.e. the proportion of customers who will buy a legitimate item once an infringing version is made unavailable), as a means of calculating ‘reclaimable’ revenue. Alternatively, it can be informative to quantify the long-term impact of a brand protection programme (e.g. considering ongoing volumes of infringements as a proportion of those seen at the commencement of the service).
The short take-away is that no single approach to quantifying ROI will work as a ‘one-size-fits-all’ solution for all services and clients, and it is generally preferable to have the option of applying one of a series of customisable calculation frameworks in any given case.
“If you have any questions or comments about any of the areas coved in Brand Protection Notebook, if you’d like to discuss any of the topics in more detail, or if you have any suggestions about areas to be covered in future editions, please don’t hesitate to reach out to me at david.barnett@snapdragon-ip.com.”
David Barnett
Director of Brand Protection | SnapDragon
Want to see how SnapDragon’s AI-powered Tech can protect your brand?
If you would like to explore how SnapDragon can accelerate your online brand protection, get in touch to schedule a demo.
We would love to hear from you, and show you what’s possible.
Get in touch today.

